Each entry can achieve a maximum of 100 points. Criteria are scored from one to ten, with one being the lowest and ten being perfect. Judges must consider a score of 5 points as average and an overall score of 50 as average.
All entries will be in Times New Roman font and 12-point, double spaced. Please notify the committee chair if there is a problem with format as the entry will be disqualified.
Judges: Please complete this form on a computer. Numbers and comments may be entered in the appropriate box without any need to format. It is difficult to read handwriting after it has been scanned or copied.
Criteria are scored from one to ten, with one being the lowest and ten being perfect. Judges must consider a score of 5 points as average and an overall score of 50 as average.
Total Scoring: The sum of points assigned to each criteria.
| 1 – 10 | 11 – 30 | 31-50 | 51-70 | 71-90 | 91-100 |
| Insufficient | Needs Improvement | Acceptable | Average | Outstanding | Exceptional |
Title Control Number
| Criteria | Points |
| 1. Mechanics
Are the mechanics of spelling, punctuation, grammar, and syntax are standard except as required for literary effect? |
|
| 2. Language
Are the word choice and vocabulary appropriate for the subject, style, characters, and target audience? It is precise, colorful, evocative? |
|
| 3. Pacing/Structure
Does the sentence structure vary and enhance the clarity, meaning, and manner of the work? Does the pacing keep the reader engaged without becoming stagnant or repetitive? |
|
| 4. Theme
Is the entry representative of the category? Is it effective, unique, or offer a fresh perspective? |
|
| 5. Opening Hook
Does the opening capture your attention and make you want to continue reading? Is it effective at setting the stage for what follows? |
|
| 6. Voice
Is the voice of the narrator clear, unique, and appropriate for the work? Is the point of view clear? If there is dialog, is it realistic? |
|
| 7. Character
Are the characters/subjects of the work credible, well developed, and appropriate to the work? Do they come to life on the page? |
|
| 8. Plot/Story
Does the structure of the work support the story? If fiction, is the plot engaging? Is there dramatic conflict that rises to a credible climax? If nonfiction, does the work examine the subject in an interesting manner? As far as you can tell, is it factually correct? |
|
| 9. Setting
Is the setting clear to the reader, whether realistic or imagined? Does it enhance the work? |
|
| 10. Overall Impression
Is the work original in the way it approaches the topic or theme? Does it evoke an emotional response? Does it transport or challenge you? Is this a work you would recommend to someone else? |
|
| Total Points | |
| Comments
Based on your assessment of the above criteria, please give detailed and constructive feedback.
|
|